|
|
This
is an official report from the University of South Carolina about ellagic
acid. Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) Dr. Nixon began studying Ellagic Acid in 1993, recently published results:
Bhagavathi
A. Narayanan, Otto Geoffroy, Mark C. Willingham, Gian G. Re Daniel
W. Nixon Cancer Prevention Program Hollings Cancer Center, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston SC 29425, USADept. of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC 29425, USAReceived
25 August 1998; received in revised form 15 October 1998, accepted 15 October
1998 Ellagic
acid is a phenolic compound present in fruits and nuts including raspberries,
strawberries and walnuts. It is
known to inhibit certain carcinogen-induced cancers and may have other
chemopreventive properties. 'Me
effects of ellagic acid on cell cycle events and apoptosis were studied in
cervical carcinoma (CaSki) cells. We
found that ellagic acid at a concentration of 10-5 M induced GI arrest within 48
h, inhibited overall cell growth and induced apoptosis in CaSki cells after 72 h
of treatment. Activation of the cdk
inhibitory protein p2l by ellagic acid suggests a role for ellagic acid in cell
cycle regulation of cancer cells. Ellagic
acid purchased from Aldrich Chemicals was purified further by crystallization
from ethanol until a purity of 99% was achieved using high-performance liquid
chromatography (HPLC) (Figs. I and
2). The highest concentration (10-3
M) of ellagic
acid was made in DMSO American Type Culture Collection(ATCC)
andlowerconcentrations(10-'-10-'M) were made with DMSO.
After confirming the purity of different dilutions of ellagic acid
through HPLC, they were aliquoted, protected from light and stored at -200C. 2.2. Cell culture Cervical
carcinoma (CaSki) cells were grown at appropriate cell culture conditions at
370C in RPMI (Gibco) supplemented with L-glutamine, 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS)
and antibiotics, in a water-saturated atmosphere of 5% C02.
As mentioned earlier, different molar
concentrations of ellagic acid were made with DMSO (ATCC grade for tissue
culture experiments).
The response of tumor cells treated with ellagic acid (in 1% DMSO) was
compared with that of tumor cells treated with 1% DMSO alone.
To determine the differential effect of ellagic acid with respect to dose
and time on cell growth, 75% confluent cells were treated with different molar
concentrations (10-5-10-9 M) and observed for 24, 48, 72 and 96 h. Trypsinized
and PBS washed cells from the above experiments were counted using a Coulter
particle counter at the specified time intervals.
Cells harvested from similar sets of experiments were used for flow
cytometry analysis. 2.3. Flow cytometry CaSki
cells treated with varying concentrations of ellagic acid and harvested at
different time periods were trypsinized, washed in PBS, and fixed in 1%
formaldehyde for 15 min on ice. After
re-washing with PBS, the cells were fixed in 80% ethanol for 30 min.
Appropriate volumes of the above cell suspension having 3 x cells were
centrifuged and the pellets of cells were re-suspended with PBS and further
treated with I mg/ml of RNAase (DNAase free) at room temperature for 30 min.
Propidium iodide (I mg/ml,- final concentration in PBS) was added and
flow cytometry analysis was performed after 30 min. Cell cycle analysis was performed using Epics xL MCL (Phoenix
Flow System). 2.4. Bromodeoxy uridine (BrdUrd)
labeling Minutes
Fig.
2. HPLC chromatogram of purified fraction of ellagic acid.
Fig. 3. Cell cycle analysis (as described in Section 2) on CaSki cells exposed to ellagic acid at IO - 3 M concentration at different time intervals. (A) CaSki cells to exposed ellagic acid at 0 h. (B) CaSki cell exposed to ellagic acid for 24 h. (C) CaSki cells to exposed ellagic acid for 48 h. (D) CaSki cells exposed to ellagic acid for 72 h. Whole
cell RNA from CaSki cells was prepared by 2.7.
Westem blot analysis the acid-guanidinium/phenol-chloroform extraction
method of Chomczynski and Sacchi [10]. Formalde-
Cells treated with ellagic acid (10-5 M) for 48 h hyde-agarose gel
electrophoresis, transfer to nitrocel- were harvested by trypsinization.
Cellular protein was lulose membranes, and hybridization were performed
extracted and Western blotting for p2lwAF'
protein as previously reported f I I ]. The probes for the consti- was
carried out using p2l wAF' Western blotting kit tutively expressed gene
glyceraidehyde phosphate with anti P21 wAF' monoclonal antibody (Calbiodehydrogenase
(GAPDH) and p53 were a 0.5 kilobase chem-@09).
Mouse monoclonal antibodies for (kbp) CDNA and a 2.7 kbp CDNA,
respectively, from p53 (DOI) were purchased from Santa Cruz Biotechthe American
Type Culture Collection (ATCC). The
nology Inc. The reactive protein
bands for p53 and probe for the p2l gene was a 1.05 kbp CDNA also). from ATCC.
Radiolabeled probes were prepared by random primed labeling. 3.
Results Cell
cycle distribution analysis of ellagic acid 3.2. Effect on DNA synthesis (BrdUrd
incorporation) The
reduced mitotic rate (Fig. 4) which was observed in video time lapse microscopy
[121, and the reduced rate of cell proliferation (Fig. 5) in ellagic acid
treated cells was consistent with the observation of a significantly lower
number of cells which showed incorporation of BrdUrd after treatment for 0-96 h.
CaSki cells treated with 10-8 M ellagic acid in the presence of BrdUrd label
showed a gradual decline in BrdUrd-labeled cells from 4 to 48 h. At 48 h 3% of
treated cells contained the BrdUrd label compared to 33% in the control cells,
indicating a significantly decreased rate of DNA synthesis (Fig. 6), which also
reflected a similar pattern of a lower number of cells in the 'S' phase (in
ellagic acid treated cells with
10-5
M) when analyzed using flow cytometry in cells
treated for 48 h. 3.3. DNA fragmentation
Fig.
7. (A) DNA fragmentation analysis using agarosc gel (1.8%) electrophoresis. (B)
RNA and Northern blot analysis (as described in Section 2) of CaSki cells
exposed to ellagic acid (10-' M) for 48 h. cells
exposed to ellagic acid (10-5 M) for 48 h). [1]
E.C. Bate-Smith, Detection and determination of ellagitannins, Phytochemistry 11
(1972) 1153-1156. 121
J.P. Perchellet, H.U. Gaii. E.M.
Perchellet. D.S. Klish, A.D.
Armbrust, Antitumor promoting activities of tannin acid, ellagic acid, and
several gailic acid derivatives in mou.-,e skin, Basic Life Sci. 59 (1992)
783-801. [3)
G.D. Stoner, A.M. Morse. lsothiocyanates and plant polyphcnois as
inhibitors of lung and esophageal cancer, Cancer Lett. 114 (1997) 113-119. [41
L.R. Dow, T.T. Chou, M.B. Bechle, C. Goddard.
R.E. Identification of tricyclic analogs related to ellagic acid as
potent/selective tyrosine protein kinase inhibitors. J. Med. Chem. 37
(1994) 224-223 1. [51
D.H. Batch, L.M. Rundhaugen, G.D. Stoner.
N.S. Pillay, W.A. Rosche, Structure-function relationships of the dietary
anticarcinogen ellagic acid, Carcinogenesis 17 (19%) 265-. 269. [6]
M. Das, D.R. Bickers. H.
Mukhtar, Effect of ellagic acid on hepatic and pulmonary xenobiotic metabolism
in mice: Studies on the mechanism of its anticucinogenic action, Carcinogenesis
6 (1985) 140c)-1413. [7]
D. Ahn, D. Putt, L. Kresty, G.D. Stoner, D. Fromm, P.F. Holienberg, The
effects of dietary ellagic acid on rat hepatic and esophageal mucosal
cytochromes p450 and Phase if enzymes, Carcinogenesis 17 (1996) 821428. [8]
R.W. Teel, Ellagic acid binding to DNA as a possible mechanism for its
antimutagenic and anticucinogenic action, Cancer Lett. 30 (1986) 329-336. [9)
K.C. Ilresiamma, R. Kuttan, Inhibition of liver fibrosis by ellagic acid,
Indian J. Physiol. Phannacol. 40
(1996) 363366. [10]
P Chomczynski, N. Sacchi, Single-step method of RNA isolation and acid
guanidinium thiocyanate-phenoichlorofonn extraction, Ann.
Biochem. 162 (1987) 156-159. [111
G.G. Re, G.R. Antoun, T.F. Ziff, Modulation Of 2 constitutive
transcriptional block at exon- I controls human c-myc expression, Oncogene 5
(1990) 1247-1250. [12]
J.A Collins, C.A. Schandle, K.K. Young, J. Vesely, M.C. Willingham,
Major DNA fragmentation is a late event in apoptosis, J. Histocbcm.
Cytochem. 45 (1997) 923-934. [13]
E.D. Fisher, Apoptosis in cancer therapy: Crossing the threshold (mini
review), Cell 78 (1994) 539-542. [14]
H.L. Hartwell, M.B. Kastan, Cell cycle control and cancer, Science 266
(1994) 1821-1828. [15]
B.C. Thompson, Apoptosis in the pathogenesis and treatment of disease,
Science 267 (1995) 1457-1461. [16)
H. Stellar, Apoptosis: mechanisms mW genes of cellular suicide, Science
267 (1995) 1445-1449. (171
T. Hunter, Oncoprotein networks, Cell 88 (1997) 333-346. [181
Y.X. Zeng, S.W. El-Deiry, Regulation of p2i WAFI/CIPI expression by
p53-independent pathways, Oncogene 12(5-8) (1996) 1557-1564. [19]
A. Ashkenazi, V.M. Dixit, Death receptors: Signaling and modulation,
Science 281 (1998) 1305-1308. CaSki
cells treated with varying concentrations of ellagic acid and harvested at
different time periods were trypsinized, washed in PBS, and fixed in 1%
formaldehyde for 15 min on ice. After
re-washing with PBS, the cells were fixed in 80% ethanol for 30 min.
Appropriate volumes of the above cell suspension having 3 x cells were
centrifuged and the pellets of cells were re-suspended with PBS and further
treated with I mg/ml of RNAase (DNAase free) at room temperature for 30 min.
Propidium iodide (I mg/ml,- final concentration in PBS) was added and
flow cytometry analysis was performed after 30 min. Cell cycle analysis was performed using Epics xL MCL (Phoenix
Flow System). 2.4. Bromodeoxy uridine (BrdUrd)
labeling BrdUrd,
an analogue of thymidine, is incorporated into DNA during S phase.
The incubation of cells with BrdUrd (30 tLg/ml) was done at different
time periods (0-96 h) with ellagic acid (10-8 M) exposure.
Tle cells, pulsed with BrdUrd every 2 h, were harvested by trypsinization
at several time intervals as mentioned earlier.
The PBS washed cells fixed in 10% fonnalin and pretreated with 0.1%
Triton XI 00, and 2 N HCI at 37'C for I 0 min were then treated with 0.1 M
sodium borate for 5 min. Mouse
monoclonal antibody (NCL-BrdUrd-Novocastra) followed by rhodamine conjugated
with goat antimouse IgG was used to detect the incorporation of BrdUrd in the S
phase cells. Minutes
Fig.
2. HPLC chromatogram of purified fraction of ellagic acid. CaSki
cells
(I X 106) treated
with and without ellagic acid (10-5 M) for 0, 24, 48 and 72 h were harvested by
trypsinizing and suspended in I ml cell lysis buffer (5 mM Tris-HCI, 20 mM EDTA
and 0.5% Triton X-100, pH 8.0) containing 100 jig/ml proteinase K and were incubated at 55'C for 4-6 h. Cells were
again treated with RNAase (10 tLg/ml) for I h at 37'C.
The supernatant was collected from the lysed cell extract and DNA
extraction was carried out with an equal volume of Tris saturated
phenol-chloroform. The
phenol-chloroform extractions were repeated twice or more to get a clear aqueous
phase. The purified samples were
ethanol precipitated, and the pellet was
air dried and re-suspended in 18 ttl of
double distilled water. The final
concentration of DNA was determined by UV absorbency at 260 nm.
DNA (10 tLgAane) was electrophoresed on 1.8% agarose gels containing
ethidium bromide (I iLg/rn]. Fig. 3. Cell cycle analysis (as described in Section 2) on CaSki cells exposed to ellagic acid at IO - 3 M concentration at different time intervals. (A) CaSki cells to exposed ellagic acid at 0 h. (B) CaSki cell exposed to ellagic acid for 24 h. (C) CaSki cells to exposed ellagic acid for 48 h. (D) CaSki cells exposed to ellagic acid for 72 h. Whole
cell RNA from CaSki cells was prepared by 2.7.
Westem blot analysis the acid-guanidinium/phenol-chloroform extraction
method of Chomczynski and Sacchi [10]. Formalde-
Cells treated with ellagic acid (10-5 M) for 48 h hyde-agarose gel
electrophoresis, transfer to nitrocel- were harvested by trypsinization.
Cellular protein was lulose membranes, and hybridization were performed
extracted and Western blotting for p2lwAF'
protein as previously reported f I I ]. The probes for the consti- was
carried out using p2l wAF' Western blotting kit tutively expressed gene
glyceraidehyde phosphate with anti P21 wAF' monoclonal antibody (Calbiodehydrogenase
(GAPDH) and p53 were a 0.5 kilobase chem-@09).
Mouse monoclonal antibodies for (kbp) CDNA and a 2.7 kbp CDNA,
respectively, from p53 (DOI) were purchased from Santa Cruz Biotechthe American
Type Culture Collection (ATCC). The
nology Inc. The reactive protein
bands for p53 and probe for the p2l gene was a 1.05 kbp CDNA also). from ATCC.
Radiolabeled probes were prepared by random primed labeling.
3.
Results 3.2. Effect on DNA synthesis (BrdUrd
incorporation) Intemucleosomal
DNA cleavage, another indicator of 'apoptosis, was evaluated.by DNA
fragmentation analysis. Apoptosis
is usually associated with the activation of nucleases and intemucleosomal
degradation of chromosomal DNA. To
see a clear DNA fragmen tation, ellagic acid treated cells that showed more than
35% apoptosis (pre-GI peak) with flow cytometry analysis (Fig. 3D) were
trypsinized and the DNA was extracted. DNA
extracted from ellagic acid treated CaSki cells was run on a 1.8% agarose gel.
Degradation of chromosomal DNA into small oligonucleosomal fragments was
clearly observed in cells treated with ellagic acid (10-5 M) after 72 h of
treatment (Fig. 7A).
Fig.
8. Western blot analysis (as described in Section 2) of CaSki 3.4. Expression of p53 and p2l CaSki
cells exposed to ellagic acid did not show any change in the level of p53 MRNA
expression and its protein. However,
ellagic acid did induce an increase in the expression of both p2l MRNA and
protein (Figs. 7B and 8, respectively), an increase that remained significant
after correction for GAPDH. Although
a small increase in the MRNA level of p53 was observed, it was found to be
consistent with the same level of increase in GAPDH. These results indicated that ellagic acid might induce GI
arrest and apoptosis by increasing p2l via a p53-independent mechanism. 4.
Discussion Plant-derived
ellagic acid, a phenolic compound found in raspberries and other plant food, has
previously been identified as a potent anticarcinogenic agent [1-9].
In this article we have shown an effect of ellagic acid on cell
proliferation inhibition, cell cycle arrest and induction of apoptosis in a
time- and dosedependent manner in cervical carcinoma cells (CaSki).
CaSki cells were found to be sensitive to the effect of ellagic acid in
inducing GI arrest within 24-48 h. Flow cytometry analysis of ellagic acid (IO -5 M) treated cells for 48 h
revealed the accumulation of 82% of the cells at the GI peak, whereas the
untreated cells showed only 30% of the cells in the GI peak.
However, the mechanism of action of ellagic acid in inducing cell cycle
arrest, decreasing DNA synthesis, with a lowered mitotic rate, and the induction
of apoptosis is not clearly understood at this point.
It is possible that all of these effects of ellagic acid are the
consequences of a single primary event in which ellagic acid initiates a cascade
of events leading to cell cycle arrest and reduced cell growth.
A multitude of factors may modulate apoptosis, including growth factors,
intracellular mediators of signal transduction and nuclear proteins regulating
gene expression, DNA replication and cell cycle regulatory genes [13-17] in
response to ellagic acid. The
present study demonstrates that ellagic acid could induce apoptosis in a cell
cycle dependent manner. Generally,
the processes leading to DNA repair involve upregulation of p2l via
p53-dependent mechanisms. In CaSki
cells, ellagic acid could not induce a remarkable increase in
the level of p53 MRNA and protein, although a
greater elevation of p2l MRNA and protein was detected following treatment with
ellagic acid. The activation of p2l
by ellagic acid could be either through a p53independent mechanism or by a
p53-dependent mechanism not involving the changes in the level of p53 protein.
Recent studies [18,19] on cell death mechanisms have shown the possible
involvement of caspases, death receptors, and mitochondrial activation in
inducing cell death, which is independent of functional p53.
However, the molecular events
induced
by ellagic acid which, in turn, upregulated p2i expression independent of p53,
and the signaling pathways leading to p2l induction, are unclear at this point.
The key findings from the present study provide evidence to support the
potential effect of ellagic acid in cell proliferation inhibition via
p2l-mediated GI arrest and cell death. Inhibition
of tumor cell proliferation and induction of cell death by ellagic acid thus,
may support a role for ellagic acid as a chemo preventive agent. Acknowledgements References [1]
E.C. Bate-Smith, Detection and determination of ellagitannins, Phytochemistry 11
(1972) 1153-1156. 121
J.P. Perchellet, H.U. Gaii. E.M.
Perchellet. D.S. Klish, A.D.
Armbrust, Antitumor promoting activities of tannin acid, ellagic acid, and
several gailic acid derivatives in mou.-,e skin, Basic Life Sci. 59 (1992)
783-801. [3)
G.D. Stoner, A.M. Morse. lsothiocyanates and plant polyphcnois as
inhibitors of lung and esophageal cancer, Cancer Lett. 114 (1997) 113-119. [41
L.R. Dow, T.T. Chou, M.B. Bechle, C. Goddard.
R.E. Identification of tricyclic analogs related to ellagic acid as
potent/selective tyrosine protein kinase inhibitors. J. Med. Chem. 37
(1994) 224-223 1. [51
D.H. Batch, L.M. Rundhaugen, G.D. Stoner.
N.S. Pillay, W.A. Rosche, Structure-function relationships of the dietary
anticarcinogen ellagic acid, Carcinogenesis 17 (19%) 265-. 269. [6]
M. Das, D.R. Bickers. H.
Mukhtar, Effect of ellagic acid on hepatic and pulmonary xenobiotic metabolism
in mice: Studies on the mechanism of its anticucinogenic action, Carcinogenesis
6 (1985) 140c)-1413. [7]
D. Ahn, D. Putt, L. Kresty, G.D. Stoner, D. Fromm, P.F. Holienberg, The
effects of dietary ellagic acid on rat hepatic and esophageal mucosal
cytochromes p450 and Phase if enzymes, Carcinogenesis 17 (1996) 821428. [8]
R.W. Teel, Ellagic acid binding to DNA as a possible mechanism for its
antimutagenic and anticucinogenic action, Cancer Lett. 30 (1986) 329-336. [9)
K.C. Ilresiamma, R. Kuttan, Inhibition of liver fibrosis by ellagic acid,
Indian J. Physiol. Phannacol. 40
(1996) 363366. [10]
P Chomczynski, N. Sacchi, Single-step method of RNA isolation and acid
guanidinium thiocyanate-phenoichlorofonn extraction, Ann.
Biochem. 162 (1987) 156-159. [111
G.G. Re, G.R. Antoun, T.F. Ziff, Modulation Of 2 constitutive
transcriptional block at exon- I controls human c-myc expression, Oncogene 5
(1990) 1247-1250. [12]
J.A Collins, C.A. Schandle, K.K. Young, J. Vesely, M.C. Willingham,
Major DNA fragmentation is a late event in apoptosis, J. Histocbcm.
Cytochem. 45 (1997) 923-934. [13]
E.D. Fisher, Apoptosis in cancer therapy: Crossing the threshold (mini
review), Cell 78 (1994) 539-542. [14]
H.L. Hartwell, M.B. Kastan, Cell cycle control and cancer, Science 266
(1994) 1821-1828. [15]
B.C. Thompson, Apoptosis in the pathogenesis and treatment of disease,
Science 267 (1995) 1457-1461. [16)
H. Stellar, Apoptosis: mechanisms mW genes of cellular suicide, Science
267 (1995) 1445-1449. (171
T. Hunter, Oncoprotein networks, Cell 88 (1997) 333-346. [181
Y.X. Zeng, S.W. El-Deiry, Regulation of p2i WAFI/CIPI expression by
p53-independent pathways, Oncogene 12(5-8) (1996) 1557-1564.
|